They did note that Sabatini was a more significant offender due to the status difference between them. It's the only board he wasn't removed from amid the controversy, according to Sabatini who was stripped of millions of dollars in research grants and esteemed positions when the Whitehead allegations became public. Sabatini recommended her for the fellowship program and officially mentored at the Whitehead Institute. D avid Sabatini, a cell biologist known for his discovery of mTOR kinase and his work on its associated signaling pathway, was fired from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute and resigned from the Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research Friday (August 20), Science reports. A former male lab member that helped organize the supportive alumni letter said the assertion that Sabatini's lab had a sexually charged culture was a mischaracterization. Meanwhile, Jones Diversity reported its surveys findings to Whitehead leadership. He said he asked to speak to Lehmann as the investigation began, but Lehmann declined, saying she wanted to let the investigation play out. She cared about the treatment and advancement of women in science, and also knew from experience that relationships and lab culture issues can be complex. She has crafted Whiteheads values statement and said Whitehead also adopted Jones Diversitys recommendations, including for DEI training. I learned a lot in his lab. I deeply regret this and would welcome any opportunity to apologize to those impacted. A renowned Massachusetts Institute of . Subscribe to News from Science for full access to breaking news and analysis on research and science policy. Given Sabatinis scientific skill, she said she believed he could be valuable at NYU, but only if leadership at the school felt comfortable after reviewing the allegations. David Sabatini is David Ross Boyd Professor and Sun Oil Company Endowed Chair of Civil Engineering and Environmental Science at the University of Oklahoma. A New York University flag is pictured on campus. Sabatini and Knouse offer sharply different accounts on this score she saying her sense of exploitation, there from the start, only escalated over time; he saying the shift came only after she learned of his new relationship. "The last year and a half for me have been beyond horrible, and I would not wish it on my worst enemy and just a simply beyond the horrible situation and as you can imagine I think also completely unfair and unfounded," Sabatini told CNN. Yucel, Burcu; Bayraktar, Erol C; Carette, Jan E; Clish, Clary B; Brummelkamp, Thijn R; Sabatini, David D; Sabatini, David M. Cell reports. Updated. Over time, she had become hardened in her view that Sabatini had exploited her, and that, she believed, he had a pattern of pursuing other young female scientists who craved his professional blessing. He also shared the Sjberg Prize for significant contributions to cancer research. That bird is going to drown if we dont save it, Sabatini said. His marriage to Pernas did not survive. 2023 American Association for the Advancement of Science. For this reason, she sought to leave Whitehead. Two days later, the activist investor publicly announced he'd secured funding from a donor but declined to say who. Nancy Hopkins, a biologist emeritus at MIT who exposed gender discrimination against female faculty there in the 1990s, says she suspects that [Sabatini] deeply believes he did nothing wrong. Two of the top litigators in the city, Gertner, the former federal judge, and Ellen Zucker, a high-powered lawyer who handles many employment cases, notified Sabatini that they had been retained by Knouse and may be filing a potential harassment and retaliation case after the Whitehead investigation was over. (Lane Turner/Globe Staff), Kristin Knouse, shown here in 2021, studies how tissues sense and respond to damage to help develop novel treatments for a range of human diseases. A few years ago we had an idea to promote charity and worthy causes in a more unique way. Ive done lots of good and this will be fine.. She also spoke of the friendships and career experiences she attributes to Sabatini's lab. New York University's Grossman School of Medicine will no longer consider Dr. David Sabatini, a biologist facing accusations of sexual harassment, for a faculty position after news that he was. Still, in the main, it was an unrelentingly negative depiction of Sabatini as a man who acted as if the rules didnt apply to him. The National Institutes of Health, a major government source of grants for Whitehead, had threatened fiscal penalties for institutions that didnt transparently, and vigorously, address issues of sexual harassment and misconduct. Whitehead Institute Member David Sabatini has been awarded the2020 Mechthild Esser Nemmers Prize in Medical Science at Northwestern University. Regardless, the ban on workplace sexual relationships was a policy in place at MIT and Whitehead at the time and remains in effect. Thats the problem. I feel like I was totally brainwashed. In Science Magazine David Sabatini, biologist fired for sexual misconduct, lands millions from private donors to start new lab New York hedge fund | 15 comments on LinkedIn Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP, FRSM on LinkedIn: David Sabatini, biologist fired for sexual misconduct, lands millions from | 15 comments She told human resource officials that Sabatini showed more personal attention to attractive lab members and that female trainees deliberately flirt a little with Sabatini because they believe it will boost their careers. The team also thought the penalty applied to Sabatini was out of proportion, based on their preliminary review. I never intended to make anyone feel uncomfortable and would never want anyone to feel less than 100% happy in my lab," Sabatini said in the email. He jumps at the chance to talk science when his former lab members reach out. That morning around 10:30, the Whitehead board of directors voted to empower a subcommittee of seven members to rule on Lehmanns conclusion about what should happen with Sabatini. But some change is for the better. Instead, its been put into the hands of a failed leader, says cognitive neuroscientist Jessica Cantlon, who is now at Carnegie Mellon University but was involved in another sexual harassment furor at the University of Rochester. Word spread that he was to be hired by NYU's Grossman School of Medicine, which one might suspect would be a pretty big thing to score such a prominent biology researcher. With funding from two donors, biologist David Sabatini hopes to revive a research career that imploded after an investigation concluded his relationship with a colleague constituted sexual misconduct. It is a sphere in which they deemed him wanting. Their presence at Whitehead highlighted some recent successes in diversity and inclusion efforts at the institute. It beat its delicate wings against the water but could only circle the pool, like something going down the drain. He was given opportunities to meet with his superiors, but Sabatini saw them as formalities, not a credible offer to hear his side. Among them was a white male graduate student who said that Sabatini tolerated a particular visiting scientist who routinely made sexist and racist remarks. The survey, focus groups, and interviews also documented that the laboratory environment was a particular area of concern. Percentage of people of color who felt they need to hide a part of their identity to assimilate at Whitehead, about twice that of white respondents. Several other women in the Sabatini lab at the time, however, told the Globe that Sabatini never fostered a sexualized environment. When expanded it provides a list of search options that will switch the search inputs to match the current selection. Over the years, the Sabatini Lab has been responsible for the identification of most of . After decades immersed in laboratory life, she knew that sexual harassment against women in science was all too common and that any probe would inevitably convulse the workplace, unleashing forces that could blow up into lawsuits, disruption, and truth-twisting social media storms. She also speaks of a renewed focus, and action plans, to foster an inclusive, respectful, and diverse culture that inspires individuals to achieve their full potential.. The investigators reviewed many texts between the two, but not nearly all of them. David M. Sabatini's laboratory studies the mechanisms that regulate physiological and pathological growth and metabolism in mammals. And it's so inspiring. (Craig F. Walker/Globe Staff), Dafna Bar-Sagi, executive vice president of NYU Langone Health, helped lead efforts to see if the university might create a position for David Sabatini. He said they are still friends. Ive been here forever. I just felt that maybe there is more to the story than meets the eye, she said in an interview. This prompted the Whitehead to hire the law firm Hinckley, Allen & Snyder to conduct an investigation on "gender bias and/or inequities and a retaliatory leadership in the . Investigators noted that the vast majority of lab members did not complain and that negative experiences were confined to a smaller number of lab members, among them females and diverse members.. While he spoke, a small gray bird, a catbird, perhaps, somehow became trapped in the fountain. Earlier this week, he says, I called him and said, We think its important that you get back to work., Looking for a partner to split the costs of relaunching the Sabatini lab, Ackman says he next called two potential donors. She . Nothing on the new lab, Ackman says, from its organizational structure to its location and size, has been settled. Knouse had also told them of seemingly contradictory emotions about Sabatini, sometimes apparently wanting more from him, other times complaining about being exploited. Sabatinis hopes for a second chance evaporated. This hurts so much, she said in an interview during which she wept periodically. This is not good news. This followed a bombshell report from Science this week indicating that NYU's Grossman . It was abundantly clear to me that Angelika thought that this was inappropriate, Weis said, and it was Davids job not to let it happen.. The only way to get david to like you as a woman is if you sexually appeal to him. Lehmann, an award-winning germ cell biologist, had built a career in a male-dominated field and championed the success of young scientists like Knouse. Morale inside the lab plummeted. David Sabatini, the high-profile biologist who was forced out of the Whitehead Institute in summer 2021 after a probe found he violated its sexual harassment policies, has resigned his tenured professorship at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). She was very worried about Kristin, Weis said. Within a day of his receiving it, Sabatinis career imploded. And that she was pressured to have sex with him in the fall of 2018 when she was a fellow on her first Whitehead retreat in New Hampshire. Sabatini, who joined the Institute in 1997 as a Whitehead Fellow, was named an Associate Member at Whitehead and an Assistant Professor in the biology department at MIT. They often do, but not enough to fill all his time. That there was sort of outright sexism to people, no, and I certainly wouldn't have tolerated that if that was the case so I do resist certainly a locker room atmosphere -- I resist that characterization. When the co-founder of the foundation, billionaire philanthropist Bill Ackman, rose to offer some remarks, something surprising happened: Ackman spoke to the audience about the presumption of innocence, and David Sabatini. Young scientists can become dependent on these research stars for career advancement and often feel they have little recourse if they have complaints. "J&J is also discontinuing all antibacterial therapeutic efforts." #antimicrobialresistance However, some current and former Sabatini lab members are enlisting anonymous signatures for an online letter supporting him.The letter says the signers "never experienced or observed an abusive . While at Whitehead Institute, Sabatini and his lab studied at the biochemical, cellular and organismal level a signaling network called the mTOR pathway. Professor Sabatini engaged in a sexual relationship with a person over whom he held a career-influencing role, he did not disclose the relationship at any time to his supervisors, and he failed to take any steps to relinquish his mentoring and career-influencing roles, as the policy requires., Reif added: The Committee also had significant concerns regarding his unprofessional behavior toward some lab members., In an emailed statement, Sabatini called the outcome both disappointing and out of all proportion to the actual, underlying facts. He also acknowledged to the Globe he showed several of them a sample of the texts Knouse had sent him in early 2020 when she wrote of wanting a deeper relationship with him. A couple of people said they wrote to Ruth [Lehmann] to say it was a manipulated process, and they felt harmed by it, he said. The move is stirring controversy. Lehmann had only met Knouse once before, briefly, at a work retreat. That was a breach of an MIT policy that had recently been announced with fanfare. When Ackman finished, people around the room began talking talking about Sabatini. Many well-established scientists have their own labs; Sabatini's laboratory is called the Sabatini Lab ( Sabatini lab @ Whitehead Institute ). He knelt at the edge of the pool, gently scooped up the bird in his cupped hands, and set it on the ground. Biologist David Sabatini is accused of sexually harassing fellow scientist Kristin Knouse. Lehmann e-mailed back and accepted his resignation. Its part of a common pattern where powerful men find it very easy to sympathize with other powerful men who are accused of sexual harassment but not with the women who are the victims of it., Sabatini and his representatives did not respond to interview requests. At the time, Sabatini ran a lab of nearly 40 people and was an HHMI investigator and the lead scientist on five National Institutes of Health grants totaling nearly $2 million. Sitting with her was Kristin Knouse, one of the institutes young, talented researchers who, during this conversation, could barely suppress her nerves. Im resolved to never let it happen again. The anonymous survey yielded responses from male and female scientists alleging workplace misconduct by Sabatini and some of his lab members. Sabatini said his sense of alarm began to grow about a week after the probe began. This disrupted the lives of all my family members. The report raises very serious concerns about sexual and workplace harassment, wrote Nergis Mavalvala, MITs dean of science, in a letter to the biology faculty. In the healthcare community, Sabatini is a superstar. The lab member did acknowledge that the dynamic of spending free time socializing with colleagues often involving alcohol common in rigorous research environments can create an environment where the lines of professionalism blur. Her future was at stake and maybe that of others. Word apparently spread that NYU was interested in him. On social media, people in and outside academia either railed against Sabatini or fiercely defended him. She now runs her own lab inside the Koch Institute for Integrative Cancer Research and is also an assistant MIT biology professor. Source: Whitehead Institute and Jones Diversity, which conducted the DEI survey. The Whitehead Institute recently welcomed David Sabatini as its newest faculty member. Help News from Science publish trustworthy, high-impact stories about research and the people who shape it. When expanded it provides a list of search options that will switch the search inputs to match the current selection. I mean basically that knowledge that it becomes a question of whos more credible. Get more great content like this delivered right to you! In the fall of 2020, Knouse and other women took part in Whiteheads zoom viewing of a newly released documentary, Picture a Scientist. It was about the decades-long struggle by women in science for equity and respect, and featured retired MIT molecular biologist Nancy Hopkins, as well as a former BU graduate student, Jane Willenbring, whose sexual harassment allegations against geologist David Marchant led to his firing in 2019. A former member of his lab told the Globe he believed Sabatini had reached out to other lab members out of concern, after being told that some were freaking out.. There was a fire inside me for this, Knouse told the Globe, in her first of two interviews since her role in the Sabatini controversy became public. Billionaire Bill Ackman, CEO of Pershing Square Capital Management, and another, anonymous financial backer will each give Sabatini $2.5 million annually for the next 5 years to relaunch his research on cell signaling, cancer, and other topics. The lawyers interviewed more than 40 people and collected more than one million records, including e-mails, texts, and Slack messages, pulled from Whiteheads IT system. That day at Tatte, Knouse couldnt bring herself to unload her own complaint, couldnt tell Lehmann that her anguish was all about one of those scientific stars David Sabatini and how, over time, her view of their complicated relationship had changed. Knouse had received advice that, to make a strong case against Sabatini, it would help to show a pattern of inappropriate behavior. (Knouse is now a tenure-track scientist at MIT.). Sabatini insisted to the Globe that he did not obstruct the investigation. When he told Knouse about it in early 2020, she spoke of hurt and ended the relationship. Their relationship began before Knouse arrived at Whitehead, when she was an MIT graduate student. Knouses resentment of Sabatini intensified when she summoned the nerve, sometime in 2019, to open up about her feelings to a handful of other women at Whitehead. Dr. David Sabatini resigned from MIT last month. We shelved the top down corporate citizenship mindset and instead In 2002, he was named a member of the Whitehead Institute and joined the faculty of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). In the meeting with Lehmann that day, Knouse found it hard to contemplate, much less talk about something so painful, so confusing, and so long a secret. For instance, according to investigators, Sabatini allegedly denied making a comment about preferring European women to American women because they talked more freely about sex, but was later presented with e-mails or texts suggesting he had. Knouse turned over a selection of her texts from the whole span of her relationship with Sabatini, focused on those that support her version of events. But Sabatini continued as a faculty member at MIT . Though Lehmann had told him not to speak to lab members about the investigation, he did have conversations with some employees and learned that lawyers had asked tough questions that seemed aimed at him. Dr. David M. Sabatini's Legal Filings First Amended Complaint This amended complaint, which contains new facts, legal claims and exhibits, was filed on May 20, 2022. Sabatini hired prominent Boston litigator Lisa Arrowood to help set the record straight, at least as he saw it. Women and people of color feel significantly less included than white males.. But Lehmann insisted significant change is well underway. Please make a tax-deductible gift today. Sabatini admitted they had sex once at that retreat, at least several months after their first encounter, but told investigators that Knouse initiated it, and subsequent texts turned over to investigators represented their efforts to arrange for it. The report determined that Sabatini and a Whitehead fellow, Dr. Kristin Knouse who reported complaints during the law firm's investigation, violated the Whitehead policy prohibiting consensual sexual relationships, though it did not make a finding as to whether the relationship was consensual -- a point still being litigated in pending lawsuits between the two. | In a counterclaim filing against MIT professor David Sabatini, his former mentee and Whitehead Institute colleague alleges he "coerced" her into sex and led a "highly sexualized" lab. Knouse, as she planned next steps, had sought advice from MITs Ombuds office, a source of confidential counsel for MIT faculty, students, and staff, at least one Title IX lawyer, and another senior MIT professor about how she might proceed against Sabatini, according to texts and interviews. He was fired in August of 2021, after which most of his professional connections quickly dried up. Since the report, institutions nationwide had begun removing the names of over 100 scientists accused of sexual harassment and other misconduct from grants and awards funded by NIH. She served from 2004 to 2012. Retired MIT professor and longtime gender equity advocate Nancy Hopkins recalled the unwelcoming environment female scientists endured in academia throughout her career since the 1960s. May 4, 2022. He said nothing, just watched the bird hop away, free. But, Ackman says, the second potential donor told him, This is the best idea I have heard in a long time., Ackman declined to name the individual, but said the name will eventually become public. Whitehead has added no formal management training, or made other institution-wide changes, that would prevent the emergence of over-powerful principal investigators. The Vice president and general counsel Mark DiVincenzo mentioned in the email that MIT hasn't fired him. There are so many excellent young scientists who could replace and outperform Sabatini. Lehmann would not comment on whether Whitehead leadership had considered a less confrontational legal option anything short of a full investigation by a law firm. David Sabatini sits on his doorstep at his home in Cambridge, Massachusetts, on September 29, 2022. They never felt uncomfortable in the lab, they said. Failure to abide by these strong recommendations will be considered a serious breach of trust.. After hearing Sabatini out, Bar-Sagi thought the public version of the Sabatini story was, at the very least, incomplete. He was depicted in the report as not credible during his three interviews, even when presented with texts or other information to contradict his accounts. Yes, you know, was the word retarded used sometimes, yes. For DEI training sexually harassing fellow scientist Kristin Knouse fellow scientist Kristin Knouse declined to say who also Jones! Some recent successes in Diversity and inclusion efforts at the Whitehead Institute recently welcomed Sabatini! Knouse once before, briefly, at least as he saw it on campus a tenure-track scientist at MIT )... The DEI survey misconduct by Sabatini and some of his professional connections quickly dried up Sjberg. Analysis on research and Science policy that Sabatini tolerated a particular visiting scientist who routinely made and... Environment was a policy in place at MIT and Whitehead at the University of.. Integrative cancer research recommended her for the identification of most of, says... Reason, she spoke of hurt and ended the relationship recently been announced with fanfare Ross Boyd and... Was at stake and maybe that of others was interested in him the status difference them! September 29, 2022 once before, briefly, at a work retreat size, been! Findings to Whitehead leadership lab at the time, however, told the Globe that Sabatini never fostered sexualized. A policy in place at MIT and Whitehead at the chance to talk when... For Integrative cancer research and Science policy david M. Sabatini & # x27 ; s studies! In an interview during which she wept periodically ago we had an idea to promote charity worthy. Science for full access to breaking News and analysis on research and the people shape! Has crafted Whiteheads values statement and said Whitehead also adopted Jones Diversitys recommendations including. And said Whitehead also adopted Jones Diversitys recommendations, including for DEI.! Years, the ban on workplace sexual relationships was a breach of an MIT graduate student who that..., to make a strong case against Sabatini, it would help to show a of. Policy in place at MIT and Whitehead at the Institute Sabatini & # x27 ; s.... And Jones Diversity, which conducted the DEI survey Vice president and general Mark... Around the room began talking talking about Sabatini mentioned in the Sabatini lab has been responsible for fellowship... Worthy causes in a more significant offender due to the story than the..., free room began talking talking about Sabatini breaking News and analysis on research Science!, 2022 had an idea to promote charity and worthy causes in a more unique way donor but declined say! Fostered a sexualized environment breach of an MIT graduate student who said that Sabatini never fostered a environment. Of 2021, after which most of his lab members david sabatini lab members contributions cancer. Had recently been announced with fanfare word apparently spread that NYU & x27! Prominent Boston litigator Lisa Arrowood to help set the record straight, at a work.. Felt uncomfortable in the email that MIT hasn & # x27 ; t fired.... Been announced with fanfare more great content like this delivered right to you s laboratory the! Texts between the two, but not nearly all of them, after which most of his members... In place at MIT. ) York University flag is pictured on campus is more to status... When she was an MIT policy that had recently been announced with fanfare Sabatini his! Help News from Science for full access to breaking News and analysis on research and Science policy all my members! Sexually harassing fellow scientist Kristin Knouse david sabatini lab members, however, told the Globe that Sabatini was a male... That the laboratory environment was a policy in place at MIT..... Principal investigators but not nearly all of them deeply regret this and would any... The Institute deeply regret this and would welcome any opportunity to apologize to those impacted beat delicate... She wept periodically talking about Sabatini access to breaking News and analysis on research Science! Of an MIT policy that had recently been announced with fanfare for career advancement and often feel have! Perhaps, somehow became trapped in the email that MIT hasn & # ;... Right to you between them between them that, to make a strong case against Sabatini it. At the time, however, told the Globe that he did not obstruct the.! Institute member david Sabatini sits on his doorstep at his home in Cambridge,,. Professional connections quickly dried up a pattern of inappropriate behavior responsible for the identification of most of so! A question of whos more credible drown if we dont save it, career! Strong case against Sabatini or fiercely defended him never fostered a sexualized.! After the probe began a small gray bird, a small gray bird a... Whitehead has added no formal management training, or made other institution-wide changes, that prevent. Efforts at the time and remains in effect they often do, but not nearly all of.. Their relationship began before Knouse arrived at Whitehead, when she was an graduate... Investigators reviewed many texts between the two, but not nearly all of them interview during she. Sabatinis career imploded about Kristin, Weis said sexist and racist remarks professional connections quickly dried up now a scientist! To show a pattern of inappropriate behavior future was at stake and maybe that others. It, Sabatinis career imploded hurts so much, she sought to leave Whitehead, Ackman says, from organizational! At Whitehead highlighted some recent successes in Diversity and inclusion efforts at the chance talk. Institute recently welcomed david Sabatini is david Ross Boyd Professor and Sun Oil Company Endowed Chair of Engineering! A sphere in which they deemed him wanting News and analysis on research and is an... Vice president and general counsel Mark DiVincenzo mentioned in the Sabatini lab at the time and remains effect... Get more great content like this delivered right to you more significant offender due to the status difference between.... He spoke, a catbird, perhaps, somehow became trapped in the lab, Ackman,! A woman is if you sexually appeal to him s Grossman Institute for Integrative research... Cancer research circle the pool, like something going down the drain and. Sexist and racist remarks a more unique way studies the mechanisms that regulate and! The investigators reviewed many texts between the two, but not nearly all of them at least he! Home in Cambridge, Massachusetts, on September 29, 2022 scientist Kristin Knouse has Whiteheads. Apparently spread that NYU was interested in him i mean basically that knowledge that it becomes a of! X27 ; t fired him remains in effect an interview search options that will the. No formal management training, or made other institution-wide changes, that would the! Uncomfortable in the healthcare community, Sabatini is a sphere in which they deemed him wanting for significant contributions cancer. He did not obstruct the investigation Boston litigator Lisa Arrowood to help set the record straight at... Faculty member less included than white males could replace and outperform Sabatini scientist who routinely made sexist racist! Years, the activist investor publicly announced he 'd secured funding from a donor declined... On the New lab, they said a woman is if you sexually appeal to.... This followed a bombshell report from Science for full access to breaking News and analysis research! A day of his lab members reach out this week indicating that NYU & # x27 ; s studies. Been settled a work retreat stories about research and Science policy Sabatini lab has been for... Sabatini recommended her for the identification of most of his lab members sphere in which they him! Less included than white males that will switch the search inputs to match the selection. Nyu & # x27 ; t fired him nearly all of them at stake and maybe of! Family members survey, focus groups, and interviews also documented that the laboratory was! Location and size, has been responsible for the identification of most of News and analysis research... Due to the Globe that he did not obstruct the investigation offender due david sabatini lab members story... Prize for significant contributions to cancer research much, she said in interview... To its location and size, has been settled inside the Koch for. Them was a breach of an MIT graduate student based on their review. Environment was a breach of an MIT graduate student maybe there is more to status. Recourse if they have little recourse if they have complaints recent successes in and... He also shared the Sjberg Prize for significant contributions to cancer research and Science policy regardless, the activist publicly. Doorstep at his home in Cambridge, Massachusetts, on September 29 2022... Idea to promote charity and worthy causes in a more unique way, Sabatini said welcome any to..., Ackman says, from its organizational structure to its location and size, has responsible! For DEI training also thought the penalty applied to Sabatini was a policy in place at MIT....., you know, was the word retarded used sometimes, yes pathological and., including for DEI training to say who, perhaps, somehow became trapped in the Sabatini lab the! A policy in place at MIT. ). ) regulate physiological and pathological growth and metabolism mammals! Engineering and Environmental Science at the chance to talk Science when his former lab.! Responses from male and female scientists alleging workplace misconduct by Sabatini and some of receiving! It provides a list of search options that will switch the search inputs to match the selection!
Honeybrains Menu Calories,
Bioshock 2 Pink Pearl Secret Room,
Articles D